RateYourProject.org is a tool designed to help teams begin the process of Productivity and Sustainability Improvement Planning (PSIP), a new technique for improving team practices. It was developed by the PSIP team, which is part of the IDEAS-ECP project.
PSIP is a lightweight methodology for improving practices used by scientific software teams. Originally envisioned for helping teams improve software engineering practices such as coding standards, testing, documenting, etc., the PSIP approach has proved general enough for other non-technical types of practices as well, such as on-boarding, communications, etc.
The core of the PSIP process comprises six steps of an iterative process. The first two steps form the self-assessment phase, where teams identify their current practices and areas that would benefit from improvement, then set goals for how to improve those practices. The next two steps form the planning phase, where teams create progress tracking cards (PTCs) to record and monitor progress towards their goals, record the current state, and create a plan for how to improve the practices. The final two steps form the execution phase, an iterative process where the plans are put into action, and progress is monitored by recording it in the PTCs as part of the team's normal task tracking activities.
Like any new idea, convincing people that it is practical and worthwhile is one thing, but actually getting them to try it out is a whole different ball game. This is particularly an issue when there are time and cost implications in trying out the idea, and if the benefits of the activity are not immediately apparent. The diagram below, courtesy of Scott Weigle, https://overexamined.life/how-overcome-procrastination/, indicates these challenges.
For PSIP, the main barrier to getting started is assessing the current project practices and identifying areas that would benefit from improvement. RateYourProject.org provides a simple and fast way to get teams on the road to improving their practices.
How it works
RateYourProject.org is a self assessment tool that works by guiding the user through a series of common development practices and allows the user to choose a response that most closely matches their current practice level using a scale of "None", "Basic", "Intermediate", and "Advanced". The scale is designed to make it easy for teams to match their practices with the practice description. Practices are grouped under the categories Better Development, Better Planning, Better Performance, Better Reliability, and Better Collaboration. This enables an overall assessment to be presented as a spider chart like this one, which clearly shows that Better Planning and Better Performance are categories that could benefit most from improvement, although there is room for improvement in all categories.
Once the overall assessment has been established, teams are able to examine the individual categories to determine what practices they could focus on for improvement. In this example, selecting the Better Planning category will then provide a more detailed assessment of the practice areas. In this case, the project could clearly benefit from creating onboarding and offboarding processes to manage staff turnover, and could also benefit from looking at how to improve contribution management, requirements analysis, and software design practices.
PSIP is a process of continuous improvement: practices needing improvement are identified, a plan is made, and then the plan is executed and the process starts again. The RateYourProject.org tool allows the current assessment to be saved, then reviewed later in order to check progress or to identify another area that could be improved. The site provides a link on the main assessment page that can be used to return to the current assessment. This provides a simple and safe mechanism for recording progress towards achieving improvement goals.
Feedback and future work
RateYourProject.org has been used to self assess project practices by a number of groups, including The HDF Group, Sandia National Laboratories, and Oak Ridge National Laboratory, as well as in tutorials that the PSIP team has presented. Feedback from users has been positive, pointing to its ease of use and the clear benefits of having a focal point for multiple team members to quickly provide their perspective when collecting input on how to improve project practices.
The PSIP team is working on a variety of improvements and enhancements to the tool. These include helping teams create progress tracking cards once they have identified practice areas for improvement, and then adding these cards to the existing task tracking systems used by the teams. We're also looking at how the tool could be integrated directly with version control hosting services such as GitHub and GitLab, more detailed assessments, and alternate presentation styles. Additional information about the tool and other PSIP related information can be found on the PSIP web page or using the PSIP Practice Guides.
M.A. Heroux et al. (2020) Lightweight Software Process Improvement Using Productivity and Sustainability Improvement Planning (PSIP). In: Juckeland G., Chandrasekaran S. (eds.) Tools and Techniques for High Performance Computing. HUST 2019, SE-HER 2019, WIHPC 2019. Communications in Computer and Information Science, vol 1190. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-44728-1_6.
E. Pourmal, R. Milewicz and E. Gonsiorowski, Using the PSIP Toolkit to Achieve Your Goals – A Case Study at The HDF Group, webinar, June 2021, (slides, recording).
Gregory Watson is Group Leader of the Application Engineering Group at Oak Ridge National Laboratory. He completed his Ph.D. in Computer Science in 2000 from Monash University. Greg's research interests include software engineering practices, development environments, programming tools, and modeling and simulation tools for high performance and scientific computing. He is founder of the Eclipse Parallel Tools Platform, and project leader of the Eclipse Science Top Level Project.